Robbery is a complex area of the law, and in many cases it can be difficult to understand the charges against you.
We have included some additional information below to help you better understand how a robbery charge could affect you.
What does the prosecution need to prove?
As discussed above, to be found guilty of robbery, the prosecution must prove several elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
1. That you stole something from another person (also known as larceny):
The prosecution must prove that you took and carried away property belonging to another person without their permission.
The prosecution must also prove that you did not intend to return the property to the owner, however usually this will be assumed where it is shown that you forcefully took property from another person.
Essentially, the elements of larceny must be proved. You can read more about larceny and what it involves.
2. The property must be taken from another person, or in the presence of another person:
Robbery only refers to situations where you take property directly from another person, or in their presence.
For example, if you broke into an empty house and stole some money, it would be considered to be a break and enter offence rather than a robbery.
However, where you entered a petrol station and demanded that the cashier give you money, it would be considered to be a robbery.
3. You must use violence in taking the property from the other person:
‘Violence’ includes the threat of violence – in other words, putting someone else in fear for their safety. This may include situations where you threaten to use violence upon another person – for example, pointing a gun at someone and asking them to hand over money. A threat could also be verbal, for example, threatening to assault someone unless they give you money.
However, you can only be found guilty of robbery where you used the threat to obtain the property – in other words, you cannot be found guilty where you threatened the other person after they had already handed over the property.
What are the other forms of robbery?
In addition to ‘robbery or stealing from the person,’ there are four other robbery offences under the Crimes Act. To be found guilty of these offences, the prosecution must prove the three elements of ‘robbery or stealing from the person,’ as discussed above, as well as some additional factors.
The possible penalties that you could receive will also depend on the type of robbery that you have been charged with.
The four additional robbery offences under the Crimes Act are:
1. Aggravated robbery (s 95 of the Crimes Act):
In order to be found guilty of ‘aggravated robbery,’ the prosecution must prove the three elements of robbery as discussed above, as well as an ‘aggravating circumstance.’ An aggravating circumstance is something that makes the robbery more serious.
There are three possible ‘aggravating circumstances’ under the Crimes Act. It is only necessary for the prosecution to prove one of these:
Where you use ‘corporal violence’ on another person: Corporal violence refers to physical injury done to another person.
Where you inflict actual bodily harm on another person: Actual bodily harm refers to harm that has some form of lasting impact – but it doesn’t have to be permanent.
Examples of actual bodily harm include bruises or scratches, and can include emotional harm where there is evidence of serious, lasting psychiatric harm.
Where you deprive someone of their liberty: This involves detaining someone against their will; for example, tying them up or locking them in a room while you commit the robbery.
2. Aggravated robbery with wounding (s 96 of the Crimes Act):
In order to be found guilty of ‘robbery with wounding,’ the prosecution must prove that you committed a robbery in aggravating circumstances (discussed above) AND that you wounded or inflicted grievous bodily harm on another person.
Grievous bodily harm refers to any ‘permanent or serious disfiguring’ of another person. An example would be where you stab or shoot someone during a robbery.
3. Armed robbery, or robbery in company (s 97 of the Crimes Act):
This means that the prosecution must prove either:
- That there was at least one other person physically present at the time of the offence, and that they were involved in committing the robbery OR
- That you were armed with an offensive weapon
The court will consider the effect of the group as a whole in committing the act or intimidating the victim.
It won’t be enough to show that the other person participated in the offence without being physically present – e.g. where someone acted as a lookout or assisted in planning the robbery.
An ‘offensive weapon or instrument’ broadly includes anything that has the potential to inflict harm upon another person. It can include things like firearms, knives, baseball bats, and syringes. However, it can also refer to things that are not generally considered weapons – such as cars and broken bottles.
You might also face harsher penalties where you were armed with a ‘dangerous weapon.’ ‘Dangerous weapons’ include things such as firearms and other prohibited weapons.
You don’t actually have to use the weapon – it will be enough that you had it on you.
4. Armed robbery or robbery in company resulting in wounding (s 98 of the Crimes Act):
This means that the prosecution must prove that you were either:
- That there was at least one other person physically present at the time of the offence, and that they were involved in committing the robbery OR
- That you were armed with an offensive weapon; AND
- You wounded or inflicted grievous bodily harm on another person.
Essentially, this means that the prosecution must prove that you committed a ‘robbery with wounding’ AND an ‘armed robbery, or robbery in company.’
What penalties am I looking at?
The type of penalty that you will receive depends on the type of robbery that you have been charged with. For example, the maximum penalties for various robbery offences are:
- For robbery or stealing from the person (s 94 of the Crimes Act), the maximum penalty is 14 years imprisonment.
- For aggravated robbery (s 95 of the Crimes Act), the maximum penalty is 20 years imprisonment.
- For aggravated robbery with wounding (s 96 of the Crimes Act), the maximum penalty is 25 years imprisonment.
- For armed robbery, or robbery in company (s 97 of the Crimes Act), the maximum penalty is 20 years imprisonment, and 25 years imprisonment if you committed the armed robbery with a ‘dangerous weapon.’
For armed robbery or robbery in company resulting in wounding (s 98 of the Crimes Act), the maximum penalty is 25 years imprisonment.
However, the penalty that you will receive will ultimately depend on your facts and circumstances. This means that in determining what kind of penalty you will receive, the court will look at things like your criminal record, whether you are someone of ‘good character,’ and whether or not you are likely to reoffend.
After the court considers all of these factors, you may actually end up with a penalty much lower than the maximum. For example, statistics show that the average penalties for robberies are:
- For robbery or stealing from the person (s 94 of the Crimes Act), the average penalty was 2.5 years imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 12 months, meaning that the average time actually spent in gaol is 12 months.
- For aggravated robbery (s 95 of the Crimes Act), the average penalty is 3.5 years imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 21.5 months, meaning that the average time actually spent in gaol is 21.5 months.
- For armed robbery, or robbery in company (s 97 of the Crimes Act), the average penalty was 3.5 years imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 21 months, meaning that the average time actually spent in gaol is 21 months.
You can increase your chances of getting a favourable outcome in your robbery case by speaking to a specialist criminal lawyer. Unlike other lawyers, specialist criminal lawyers have a wealth of knowledge and experience fighting robbery charges – so they will know what to do to ensure that you get the best result.
At Sydney Criminal Lawyers® we pride ourselves on being the best robbery lawyers in Sydney. Our expert lawyers have years of experience winning robbery cases. So call us today on (02) 9261 8881 and find out how we can help you beat your robbery charge.